TL;DR
Get workout gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
A large South Korean observational study found that adults who had obesity at ages 20 to 39 had higher 10-year cancer incidence than normal-weight peers, with risk increasing across BMI categories. Abdominal fat was also associated with higher risk, but the study cannot show that obesity caused cancer or that weight loss would prevent it.
A study of 6.3 million South Korean adults found that people classified as having obesity at ages 20 to 39 had higher cancer incidence over the following decade than those in the normal-weight category. The observational findings, published in Annals of Internal Medicine, also linked abdominal obesity with additional risk, but do not establish that excess weight caused the cancers.
The researchers used national health insurance data to identify adults who had a national health examination between 2009 and 2012. Participants had a mean age of 30.9 years, and 59.3% were men. During a mean follow-up of 11.2 years, the study recorded 151,893 cancers. The analysis adjusted for factors including smoking status, alcohol intake, physical activity, income, residential area and existing health conditions.
Ten-year cumulative cancer incidence was 1.84% among normal-weight participants, compared with 2.24% for class I obesity and 2.62% for class II obesity, using BMI categories defined for Asian populations. Compared with normal-weight adults, the estimated cancer hazard rose across categories: 1.10 for overweight, 1.22 for class I obesity and 1.43 for class II obesity. These are relative hazard estimates, not percentages of participants who developed cancer.
The researchers reported higher associations among men than women across the BMI categories. They also found that abdominal obesity added to risk beyond BMI in some comparisons: the 10-year incidence for people with class I obesity and abdominal obesity was 2.45%, versus 2.13% for class I obesity without abdominal obesity. Rates varied by cancer type; the report identified thyroid, endometrial and ovarian cancers among those with the highest 10-year rates in its analyses. Breast cancer rates were lower among participants with obesity than among normal-weight participants, a finding that does not establish a protective effect.
Cancer Risk Signals in Young Adults
The study addresses a gap in research: many earlier investigations of obesity and cancer have included limited information about people in their 20s and 30s. Its large sample and extended follow-up provide evidence that the association between weight categories and cancer incidence can be observed in a young adult population, rather than only in older groups.
For readers, the findings point to a population-level association, not an individual prediction. The absolute difference between the normal-weight and class II obesity groups was 0.78 percentage points over 10 years in this study. The authors described the absolute risk differences as modest, while noting that the association appeared across multiple cancer types. The results do not establish that a particular person will develop cancer or that weight loss will reduce their risk.
The findings may inform future research and discussions about prevention, especially as obesity prevalence rises and early-onset cancers receive attention. They do not, on their own, support changing screening guidance for young adults. The authors said further research is needed to determine whether weight loss in early adulthood changes later cancer risk and whether earlier screening is appropriate for any group.
Products Worth Considering
Withings Body Smart Wi-Fi and Bluetooth Body Composition Scale
Fitbit Versa 4 Fitness Smartwatch – Black/Graphite
Fitbit Versa 2 Health and Fitness Smartwatch with Bonus Bands
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How the South Korean Study Was Built
The study defined young adults as ages 20 to 39 and drew on a national health insurance database covering 2009 to 2021. Eligible participants had at least one national health examination during 2009-2012; BMI was grouped under World Health Organization criteria for Asian populations. Researchers also assessed waist circumference and abdominal obesity, allowing them to compare central fat measures with BMI.
In a statement to MedPage Today, Alpa Patel of the American Cancer Society, who was not involved in the research, said the study adds information about early-onset cancers that are less represented in older research. She also described its 2009-2012 starting period as a more contemporary study population. Patel cautioned that the analysis reported smoking status but not smoking intensity or duration, factors that can affect cancer risk.
The report places the findings alongside existing evidence that more than a dozen cancers are associated with overweight and obesity. It also cites prior research suggesting that overweight and obesity may account for up to 10% of the global cancer burden. That estimate is from other research and is not a result calculated by this South Korean study.
“Although the absolute risk differences were modest, the consistency of associations across multiple cancer types and the young age of the population underscore the potential importance of early-life weight management.”
— Kyungdo Han, PhD, of Soongsil University in Seoul, and co-authors
Causation and Individual Risk Remain Open
Because this was an observational study, it can identify associations but cannot determine that obesity caused the cancers. Adjustments for measured factors such as smoking, alcohol use and activity do not rule out the influence of unmeasured factors or limitations in how those factors were recorded. Patel specifically noted that smoking intensity and duration were not reported.
The study also does not show whether intentional weight loss in young adulthood reduces later cancer incidence. Its findings come from South Korea, and it is not clear from the report how closely the estimates would apply to populations with different demographics, health systems or patterns of risk. The higher relative hazards in men and differences by cancer type also do not provide a basis for predicting an individual’s outcome.
The report gives category-level incidence and hazard estimates, not a screening recommendation. Whether young adults with obesity benefit from earlier or different cancer screening remains unresolved. The authors called for further studies to address that question.
Prospective Studies and Screening Questions
The next research step identified by the study authors is prospective work testing whether intentional weight loss in early adulthood is associated with lower subsequent cancer risk. Future studies could also examine how waist measures, weight changes over time and more detailed information about smoking and other exposures affect the relationship.
Researchers would need additional evidence before the findings could support a change in screening practice. For now, the study adds population-level evidence about obesity and cancer incidence among young adults, while the effects of weight loss and the value of targeted early screening remain open questions.
Key Questions
Does the study prove that obesity causes cancer?
No. It was an observational study, which found an association between weight categories and cancer incidence but cannot establish cause and effect.
How different were the 10-year cancer rates?
The reported cumulative incidence was 1.84% for normal-weight participants, 2.24% for class I obesity and 2.62% for class II obesity. These are group-level estimates from the South Korean study, not predictions for an individual.
Did abdominal fat matter separately from BMI?
The researchers reported additional risk associated with abdominal obesity in some comparisons. For class I obesity, 10-year incidence was 2.45% with abdominal obesity and 2.13% without it.
Does the study mean young adults with obesity need earlier cancer screening?
No screening change was established. The authors said further research is needed to identify whether early screening is warranted for young adults with obesity.
Would losing weight reduce cancer risk?
This study did not test weight loss or show that it reduces cancer risk. The authors called for prospective studies to investigate that question.
Source: medpagetoday.com
